Justifying Republican Patriotism

  • Szilárd János Tóth PhD student, Doctoral School of Political Science, Corvinus University of Budapest
Keywords: republicanism, patriotism, freedom as non-domination, love, loyalty

Abstract

My paper is on the republican version of patriotism and its justification, as developed most systematically by Philip Pettit and Maurizio Viroli. The essence of the justification is as follows: patriotism is to be viewed as valuable insofar as it is an indispensable instrument for the upholding of the central republican ideal, namely freedom understood as non-domination. My primary aim is to evaluate the normative force of this justification. In the first section, I introduce minimal descriptive definitions of the concepts of patriotism and the patria. Second, I reconstruct the republican patria-ideal to which patriotism is linked to. In the third section, I reconstruct the republican justification of patriotism. Finally, I ask what we justify when we justify republican patriotism. Two views are prevalent in this regard. According to the first, republican patriotic motivation, similarly to its justification, ought to be instrumental itself too (Pettit, Viroli). I argue that this view is untenable, since it is in tension with the minimal definition of patriotism. The conclusion is that the other view – according to which the patriotic motivation ought to be of intrinsic character (Miller) – possesses greater normative force.

References

Andronache, Laura (2009), Contemporary Republican Strategies for ’Civic Virtue’ and the Notion of Political Obligation. Budapest: PhD dissertation, CEU.
–. (2006), “Contemporary Republican Theories: In Search of Solidarity”, in Iseult Honohan and Jeremy Jennings (eds.), Republicanism in Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge, pp. 109–122.
Berlin, Isaiah (1999), Négy esszé a szabadságról [Four Essays on Liberty], translated by Ferenc Erős and Gábor Berényi. Budapest: Európa könyvkiadó.
Canovan, Margaret (2000), “Patriotism Is Not Enough”, British Journal of Political Science 30(3): 413–432.
Dietz, Mary G. (2002), “Patriotism: A Brief History of the Term”, in Igor Primoratz (ed.), Patriotism. Amherst: Humanity Books, pp. 201–215.
Gilbert, Margaret (2009), “Pro Patria: An Essay on Patriotism”, Ethics 13(4): 319–346.
Heller, Ágnes (1994), Általános etika [General Ethics], translated by Berényi Gábor. Budapest: Cserépfalvi.
Honohan, Iseult (2002), Civic Republicanism. New York: Routledge.
Huoranszki, Ferenc (1999), “Szerződéselmélet és politikai kötelezettség [Contractarianism and Political Obligation]”, in Filozófia és utópia. Budapest: Osiris, pp. 123–190.
Keller, Simon (2007), “How Patriots Think, and Why It Matters”, in Igor Primoratz and Aleksandar Pavković (eds.), Patriotism. Philosophical and Political Perspectives. Hampshire: Ashgate, pp. 63–74.
Kleinig, John (2015), “The Virtue in Patriotism”, in: John Kleinig, Simon Keller and Igor Primoratz, The Ethics of Patriotism: A Debate. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell, pp. 19–47.
–. (2014), On Loyalty and Loyalties. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
–. (2007), “Patriotic Loyalty”, in I. Primoratz and A. Pavković (eds.), Patriotism. Philosophical and Political Perspectives, pp. 37–54.
Laborde, Cécile (2008), Critical Republicanism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
–. (2002), “From Constitutional to Civic Patriotism”, British Journal of Political Science 32(4): 591–612.
MacIntyre, Alasdair (2002), “Is Patriotism a Virtue?”, in I. Primoratz (ed.), Patriotism, pp. 43–58.
Miller, David (2016), Strangers in Our Midst. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Margalit, Avishai (2017), On Betrayal. Harvard: Harvard University Press.
Maynor, John (2003), Republicanism in the Modern World. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Nathanson, Stephen (1993), Patriotism, Morality, and Peace. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
–. (1989), “In Defense of Moderate Patriotism”, Ethics 99(3): 535–552.
Pogonyi, Szabolcs (2012), Közösségelvűség és politikai liberalizmus [Communitarianism and Political Liberalism]. Budapest: L’Harmattan.
Pettit, Philip (2017), “Political Realism Meets Civic Republicanism”, Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 20(3): 331–347.
–. (2014), Just Freedom. A Moral Compass for a Complex World. New York: W. W. Norton.
–. (2012), On the People’s Terms. A Republican Theory and Model of Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
–. (2004), “The Common Good”, in Keith Dowding, Robert E. Goodin and Carole Pateman (eds.), Justice and Democracy. Essays for Brian Barry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 150–169.
–. (1997), Republicanism. A Theory of Freedom and Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Priestley, Joseph (1993), Political Writings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Primoratz, Igor (2015), “Patriotism: A Two-Tier Account”, in: J. Kleinig, S. Keller and I. Primoratz, The Ethics of Patriotism: A Debate, pp. 73–104.
–. (2007), “Patriotism and Morality: Mapping the Terrain”, in I. Primoratz and A. Pavković (eds.), Patriotism: Philosophical and Political Perspectives, pp. 17–36.
–. (2002), “Patriotism: Morally Allowed, Required, or Valuable?”, in I. Primoratz (ed.), Patriotism, pp. 187–200.
Sandel, Michael (1998), “Reply to Critics”, in Anita L. Allen and Milton C. Regan (eds.), Debating Democracy’s Discontent. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 319–335.
Scheffler, Samuel (2001), Boundaries and Allegiance. Problems of Justice and Responsibility in Liberal Thought. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Singer, Irving (2009), Philosophy of Love. A Partial Summing-Up. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Soutphommasane, Tim (2012), The Virtuous Citizen. Patriotism in a Multicultural Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Velleman, J. David (1999), “Love as a Moral Emotion”, Ethics 109(2): 338–374.
Viroli, Maurizio (2002), Republicanism, New York: Hill and Wang.
–. (1995), For Love of Country. An Essay on Patriotism and Nationalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Published
2019-06-24
Section
STUDIES AND ARTICLES